The 7 Best Cookie Shops in Winnipeg to Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth
Ever wonder what heaven looks like? For me, it’s not some mystical cloud or golden gate. It’s the distinct, irresistible aroma of freshly baked cookies wafting through Winnipeg’s charming neighborhoods!
Growing up in this sweet-toothed locale, I’ve had more cookie cravings than I’d like to admit—and probably more goodies than I should’ve eaten!
But who’s counting anyway? From gooey chocolate chips to decadent oatmeal raisin, our city has some hidden cookie gems that’ll make you forget all about counting calories.
So, if you’ve got a soft spot for indulgence, buckle up, because I’ve done the hard (and tasty) work for you. Here are the best cookie shops in Winnipeg that’ll have you doubling down on dessert!
1. Cookie by George
– Media credit: cookiesbygeorge
Location: 360 Main St
Website: http://www.cookiesbygeorge.com/
Phone: +1 204 949 0588
Operating hours: Monday to Friday: 7:00 am – 3:00 pm
Must-have: Shortbread Chocolate Chunk with Pecans
Cookies by George is an iconic cookie shop that has been delighting Canadians since 1983.
They’re all about quality—using only the finest ingredients, no matter the cost. And trust me, that dedication shines through in every bite.
Their cookie lineup is drool-worthy, featuring classics like Macadamia Nut Chocolate Chunk, George’s Peanut Butter, and the ever-indulgent Reverse Almond Chocolate Chunk.
But if there’s one cookie you can’t miss, it’s their Shortbread Chocolate Chunk with Pecans. Picture rich, buttery shortbread paired with generous chunks of Valrhona chocolate and just the right amount of pecan crunch.
These cookies are baked in-store daily—no pre-packaged shortcuts here. And since they’re made with natural ingredients and no preservatives, they feel like a treat you can feel good about.
2. Sugar Mama Cookie Company
– Media credit: sugarmamacookiecompany
Location: 184 Provencher Blvd
Website: http://www.sugarmamacookiecompany.com/
Phone: +1 204 306 6262
Operating hours: Monday to Saturday: 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
Must-have: Assorted Bakery Cookie Box
Sugar Mama Cookie Company whips up all kinds of gourmet treats, from bakery cookies that change flavors every week to custom sugar cookies that are almost too good to eat (but believe me, once you taste them, all bets are off!).
One of my personal favorites is their Assorted Bakery Cookie Box. Think of it as a treasure chest of cookies—you never know what flavors you’ll find inside, and that’s where the fun begins! Each bite feels like unwrapping a delicious surprise.
They’ve also got some wild creations, like their Christmas Chip Cookie, Confetti (Peanut Butter Marshmallow), Gluten-Friendly Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, and even a Vegan Snickerdoodle that’s so good you won’t miss the dairy.
And if you love surprises as much as sweets, they’ve got this Cookie Club subscription where you get a box of cookies delivered to your door every month. How cool is that?
3. Goodies Bake Shop Ltd.
– Media credit: goodiesbakeshop
Location: 1124 Ellice Ave
Website: https://www.goodiesbakeshop.com/
Phone: +1 204 949 2480
Operating hours:
- Monday to Friday: 9:00 am 10:00 pm
- Saturday: 9:00 am – 9:00 pm
- Sunday: 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
Must-have: Biggest Imperial Cookie
Since 1984, this bakery has been the go-to place for cakes, pies, pastries, and Italian-inspired gelato and sorbet. If you’ve ever attended an event around here and been amazed by the dessert, there’s a good chance it came from Goodies.
Now, let me tell you about their crown jewel: the Biggest Imperial Cookie. It’s massive, designed to serve eight to ten people, but no judgment if you decide to keep it all for yourself!
Made from their signature Imperial Sugar Cookie, it’s filled and topped with just the right amount of Apple Raspberry Jam and finished with their velvety Imperial Icing. And, of course, it wouldn’t be complete without the iconic red dot on top—a treat fit for royalty.
4. Sweet Impressions
– Media credit: sweetimpressionsbakery
Location: 1817 Corydon Ave
Website: http://www.sweetimpressions.ca/
Phone: +1 204 237 0743
Operating hours: Monday to Sunday: 10:00 am – 5:00 pm
Must-have: Chocolate Chip Cookies
Sweet Impressions has made its name as a completely nut-free bakery—yep, 100%—so if you’ve got peanut or tree nut allergies in the family, you can finally relax and enjoy without worry.
They even go the extra mile with a variety of vegan options, so there’s something sweet for everyone to indulge in.
Their menu is a haven for anyone who loves sugary foods. Custom cookies, cupcakes, cakes—you name it, they bring your dessert dreams to life.
But what truly steals the show are their beautifully decorated custom cookies. Each one is so intricately designed that you’ll hesitate to take that first bite! These pastries are ideal for birthdays, weddings, or any special event you want to add a little flair to.
Oh, and before you leave, don’t skip their Chocolate Chip Cookies! As someone who’s indulged in more than a few, I can confidently say they’ve mastered the balance of chewy and crispy. Packed with high-quality chocolate chips, every bite is pure happiness!
5. High Tea Bakery
– Media credit: highteabakery
Location: 2103 Portage Ave
Website: http://www.highteabakery.com/
Phone: +1 204 775 0264
Operating hours:
- Monday to Friday: 10:00 am – 5:00 pm
- Saturday: 10:00 am – 4:00 pm
Must-have: Imperial Cookies
Everything at High Tea Bakery is baked fresh daily with top-notch ingredients—I mean nothing artificial, just simple, high-quality goodness.
The moment you step inside, you’re greeted by a tempting display of custom-decorated cookies, delicate dainties, moist cupcakes, and a selection of premium teas and coffee to pair them with.
If it’s your first time here, order the Imperial Cookies. These aren’t just any cookies—they’ve been served to none other than Her Majesty the Queen of England herself!
Seriously, they’re as regal as cookies can get. And they don’t just taste amazing; they’re beautifully decorated too.
6. Extravagant Cookies
– Media credit: extravagantcookies
Location: 1225 St Mary’s Rd unit 19
Website: http://www.extravagantcookies.ca/
Phone: +1 204 253 8432
Operating hours:
- Monday to Friday: 10:00 am – 9:00 pm
- Saturday and Sunday: 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
Must-have: Extravagant Cookie Bouquet
Extravagant Cookies, a women-owned business in Winnipeg, has turned the idea of gift-giving into something fun and delicious.
Their Extravagant Cookie Bouquets combine the charm of flowers with the indulgence of hand-decorated sugar cookies.
These unique arrangements are designed to match any theme, making them perfect for big events, corporate parties, or those “just because” moments when you want to show someone you’re thinking of them.
7. Pinky’s Bakeshop
– Media credit: pinkys_bakeshop
Location: 439 Stradbrook Ave
Website: https://www.pinkysbakeshop.com/
Phone: +1 204 453 2253
Operating hours: Tuesday to Saturday: 11:00 am – 5:00 pm
Must-have: Toffee Salted Caramel Sandwich Cookie
Pinky’s is famous for mixing South Asian flavors with classic Western-style pastries, which makes it such a treat.
They have everything from cupcakes to brownies, but if you go, you have to try their Toffee Salted Caramel Sandwich Cookie. It consists of two toffee cookies filled with vanilla buttercream and a salted caramel center.
The combination of the rich toffee flavor with the creamy buttercream and the hint of salted caramel creates the perfect balance of sweetness and saltiness.