Best Insurance Brokers in Winnipeg

The 5 Best Insurance Brokers in Winnipeg

Featured Image Source: Pexels

Every day, we face risks concerning our lives, properties, assets, and finances. You can take many actions to secure your future, and one of these is insuring yourself and your properties.

There are many types of insurance, but it’s recommended to have the following: life, health, auto, and home insurance. Rate shopping for all of these may take much of your time and energy, so why not just find the best insurance brokers in Winnipeg to do it for you?

In this article, we’ll be talking about how you can choose the best insurance broker. We also listed down the average insurance premiums and a list of FAQs to help you because your life and properties literally depend on your choices.

How to Choose the Best Insurance Brokerage

Before we tell you of the top firms for insurance brokerage, you should first know how to choose the perfect one for you.

First, you should find an insurance broker who has enough experience in the kind of insurance you’d like to get. For example, if you’re looking for auto insurance, you have to find a broker with numerous connections with insurance providers offering auto policies.

Next, you should also find an insurance broker who has excellent communication skills. They should be reliable and responsive as you’ll be communicating with them when it comes to payments, policy updates, and of course, insurance claims.

Lastly, you should find an insurance broker with positive reviews to ensure you’re getting high-quality customer services. This criterion will also help you get an insurance broker who’ll listen to what you really want and need.

Average Costs for Insurance Policies

Insurance brokerages get a commission based on your premiums so before you seal the deal with one, make sure you’ll be paying more for your premium than for their commission. Here are the average prices for each type of insurance policy.

Type of InsuranceAverage Monthly Cost
Home$89
Condo$37
Renter$23
Auto$95
Life (based on preferred health status)$30 (males) $25 (females)
Health$45 (males) $80 (females)

You should also know that life insurance policies depend on your gender, lifestyle and hobbies, medical history, and age. Males, older applicants, and those with dangerous hobbies may get a higher rate for life insurance.

The Best Insurance Brokerage Firms in Winnipeg

Now that you know what to find in an insurance brokerage firm, you can now choose your broker with our list of the best insurance brokers in town.

1.   Wyatt Dowling Insurance Brokers

Wyatt Dowling Insurance Brokers' HomepageWyatt Dowling Insurance Brokers' Homepage
BEST FOR   Accessibility
SERVICESAuto, motorcycle, business, home, life, marine, travel, and farm insurance plans
WEBSITEhttps://www.wyattdowling.ca/
ADDRESS1353 McPhillips St, Winnipeg, MB R2X 3A6
CONTACT DETAILS(204) 949-2620 [email protected]
OPERATING HOURSMonday – Tuesday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Wednesday – Friday: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Wyatt Dowling is one of the biggest insurance brokerage firms in Winnipeg. It is also a part of the bigger firm, Western Financial Group, which has ties to Wawanesa insurance.

This firm offers all types of plans, from auto to recreational plans. One of the best things about Wyatt Dowling is that it strives to build long-term client relationships so that you won’t have any problems with communication.

This firm is also active in local charity efforts through its charity, Western Communities Foundation. Since 2002, this charity has spent $3.6 million funding housing, education, and public health projects all over the country.

Pros

  • Builds long-term client relations
  • Active in local and national charity efforts
  • Wide range of insurance plans
  • 11 locations in Winnipeg

Cons

  • Limited to Wawanesa and Western Financial’s insurance plans

Customer Reviews

As one of Winnipeg’s top insurance brokerages, Wyatt Dowling continues to be responsive and reliable, just as these reviews will tell you:

“Kierra provided us with amazing service. We needed home insurance in 2 days and she worked so hard to get it to us in time. She was so quick and handled everything like a pro (well, not LIKE a pro, she is one). Thank you!!”

“11/10 Great customer service I just want to give a big thank you to Preeti Kashyap for her amazing customer service she’s been helping me out for the past 2 years answering all my questions and calls and continuing to do so , if you have any questions regards to insurance she will gladly help you!”

2.   Nation West Insurance Brokerage

Nation West Insurance Brokerage's Homepage
BEST FOR   24/7 claims hotline
SERVICESAuto, home, life, business, travel, and boat insurances
WEBSITEhttps://www.nationwest.ca/
ADDRESS1610 Kenaston Blvd #100, Winnipeg, MB R3P 0Y4
CONTACT DETAILS(204) 453-8888
OPERATING HOURSMonday – Thursday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Friday: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Sunday: 12:00 PM – 5:00 PM

Nation West Insurance Brokerage can help you find the most competitive prices for auto, home, life, and even business insurance plans. It prides itself on finding smart solutions for all its clients’ needs.

What this firm guarantees is a wide range of choices because it has ties with 25 insurance providers. These choices include insurance giants such as CAA, Intact, SMI, and Wynward.

With its online forms, you can also quickly pay your premiums. Besides, Nation West also has a responsive 24/7 line for emergency insurance claims.

Pros

  • Focus on commercial, home, and auto insurances
  • Convenient online payments
  • 24/7 claims hotline

Cons

  • Claiming only via calls

Customer Reviews

Customers appreciate Nation West’s approachable yet professional services. Here are some reviews to tell you more about how Nation West impresses its customers:

“Best insurance brokerage I ever went. No more rate shopping to do by myself. Not only provide me the best rate, but also the best service I ever get. Staffs are friendly, especially the guy Frank or Freddy( sorry, I’m bad on remembering names). He is super nice. He is very patient to hear what my needs are,  and provide the best insurance meet my needs.”

“We called this (only opened) location 15 minutes before closing, they gave us instructions over the phone, waited for us to arrive with all the documents then they helped us with all our insurance needs. Both representatives are super passionate and friendly. We will definitely come back with all our future endeavors. Thanks you!”

3.   Reider Insurance

Reider Insurance's Homepage
BEST FOR   Connections with international financiers
SERVICESAuto, home, boat, travel, and business insurance
WEBSITEhttps://www.reider.ca/
ADDRESS925 Leila Ave, Winnipeg, MB R2V 3J7
Other locations
CONTACT DETAILS(204) 338-3888
OPERATING HOURSMonday – Friday: 9:30 AM – 8:00 PM
Saturday: 9:30 AM – 5:30 PM

Reider Insurance is a family-owned business with six locations in the city alone. It represents a variety of insurance providers, from local to international finance groups.

With its various connections, it manages over $20 million per year for both personal and business clients. For business insurance plans, Reider caters to small to large-sized businesses.

And even if Reider Insurance is a locally-based insurance brokerage, it can still offer its services to residents in other western provinces, including Saskatchewan, Alberta, and British Columbia.

Pros

  • Business insurance for small to large-sized companies
  • Connections with local to international insurance providers
  • Wide reach of services

Cons

  • Limited types of insurance plans
  • Not the best for Autopac

Customer Reviews

As a family-business, Reider Insurance knows what you and your household need. Here are reviews that share how welcoming Reider Insurance can be:

“The staff was very receptive to my needs and friendly as family!!! I feel professional buisness could use this company as a model to serve the public in a manner that one should expect to be served…. would I use them again? Exclusively!!!”

“Received some of the best service I’ve ever had at an insurance brokerage! The staff there were so polite and knowledgeable helped make my move back to Manitoba nice and smooth! If you are looking for a new broker I highly recommend reider insurance in particular Justine! She was fabulous!”

4.   Coughlin Insurance Brokers

Coughlin Insurance Brokers' Homepage
BEST FOR   Variety of insurance choices
SERVICESAuto, home, life, business, group, travel, and boat insurance
WEBSITEhttps://www.coughlin.com/
ADDRESS1570 Regent Ave W #6, Winnipeg, MB R2C 3B4
Other locations
CONTACT DETAILS(204) 953-4620
OPERATING HOURSMonday – Tuesday: 9:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday – Friday: 9:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Saturday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Established in 1971, Coughlin Insurance Brokers has been providing only the best insurance plans to Manitobans. It stays true to its promise for unparalleled services by providing 24/7 response through its website and hotline.

Besides, Coughlin is also accessible because it has three locations in the city. The best insurance brokers in Winnipeg’s Coughlin also take time to really listen to your needs so you can get an insurance plan that matches your budget and lifestyle.

Coughlin’s services span from Manitoba and Ontario to the Northwest Territories, so it also has numerous insurance partners. Thus, you can choose among 32 insurance providers with Coughlin Insurance Brokers.

Pros

  • Offers all types of insurance plans
  • 24-hour response via website and hotline
  • 32 insurance partners
  • Proficient in English, Hindi, and Punjabi

Cons

  • Limited office locations in Winnipeg

Customer Reviews

Read these customer reviews to know more about what you may experience, too, should you choose Coughlin Insurance Brokers:

“Coughlin insurance has been a fantastic experience in insuring my house! One of the brokers went above and beyond in finding me the perfect rate and really personalizing the experience of getting my first home insured. I would recommend Coughlin to any friend, especially first-time home buyers!”

“Very friendly front desk staff.  He answered ask our questions and gave very sound advice. Betty engaging and have us ask the time we needed to think thin has over before making a decision.”

5.   King Insurance Brokers Agency

King Insurance Brokers Agency's Homepage
BEST FOR   Additional services
SERVICESHome, auto, life and disability, business, farm, and travel insurance
WEBSITEhttps://www.kinginsurance.com/
ADDRESS829 Henderson Hwy, Winnipeg, MB R2K 2L2
CONTACT DETAILS(204) 661-2629 [email protected] [email protected]
OPERATING HOURSMonday – Friday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

With over 60 years of services, King Insurance has found ways for its clients to save up while still getting the best-valued insurance premiums. As a family business, it will also treat you with much respect and consideration.

King Insurance also has an online form on its website for timely filing of claims. Furthermore, they have a 24/7 hotline so you can contact them for claims and updates during emergencies.

Aside from insurance services, King Insurance can also help you manage your finances with its financial planning services. This additional service can surely help you budget your money and prioritize necessities.

Pros

  • Online forms for claims
  • 24/7 hotline for claims
  • Additional financial planning services

Cons

  • Only one location in Winnipeg

Customer Reviews

King Insurance offers one of the best customer services in Winnipeg, which is why it has amassed various 5-star reviews from its clients such as these:

“One time I needed to renew my auto insurance and I came a few minutes after they had closed. The owners were in the parking lot and they saw me, opened their office and renewed my insurance …. Above and beyond!!!”

“Extremely satisfied with their customer service and the way they handle there customers needs they go above and beyond when they can. THANK YOU Kim”

FAQs About the Best Insurance Brokers in Winnipeg


We hope we answered your questions about finding the best insurance brokers in Winnipeg. Just make sure you communicate your needs and limitations with your chosen insurance broker so you can arrive with an insurance policy of great value.

While insurances are useful safety nets, there are also other ways of protecting your assets. If you’re looking for different ways to protect your properties, you can also check out our list of the best locksmiths in Winnipeg that’ll keep your safes and house locks updated and secure.